Quote Originally Posted by sputtyduke View Post
I am a Macalester, derived from MacAlister, a sept of MacDonald. I am proud of my ancestry, I'm even a representitive of Clan MacAlister Society. But I don't own a MacAlister tartan kilt. Why? It's an unappealing arrangement of loud, clashing colors. I'm sure, at one time, it was quite fashionable. I would bet that there are many who would say that it is still lovely. Not for me thanks. I prefer subdued, earthy tones like browns and greens, I own a Buchanan hunting, a black watch, a black Stewart, an acu cammo traditional, and a brown duck Utilikilt (for around the house and camping) I also have a no name great kilt that I wear to renaissance faires. I'm getting married this fall and my fiancee wants my kilt to be fall color themed. I am leaning toward MacAlister of Skye.This decision is 2 parts because at least it's a familial tartan and 1 part because it is relatively fall "ish" . I'm sure everyone has a favorite (or many) I am just curious what you ladies and gents lean toward and why. Do you wear your clan tartan or do you prefer "new" tartans such as national tartans or do you prefer a solid colored kilt?
You should check for "Weathered" colours in your tartan- I think Lochcarron has one of the better selections (but apparently not MacAlister).

I belong to the MacGregors, and thus (coupled with a serious lack of funds) I've "always" worn MacGregor. My first kilt was in the Modern colours, but I finally got a Weathered MacGregor 4yd box pleat from Matt Newsome (the best kilt EVER!) and I definitely love it! I've a Tank in "Hunting" MacGregor (aka MacGregor of Cardney) that I am very fond of as well.

I too am partial to the more muted, earth tone tartan colours, and the Weathered McIntosh (Mother's family) is another favourite of mine as well as the Hunting Stewart.


Quote Originally Posted by YoungMan View Post
As for a favorite, undecided is my nature. I did see a MacGregor W that I really liked a while back.
Aaaah, yeah! Weathered MacGregor's got it goin' OWN!