Threaded View
 Jock Scot What would the Victorians... 21st July 09, 01:32 AM
 caig Victorian Dress 21st July 09, 01:45 AM
 Bugbear * Oops, I just noticed this... 21st July 09, 01:49 AM
 Paul THE TIE!
Joking :) You... 21st July 09, 02:16 AM
 M. A. C. Newsome I can't tell how your kilt is... 21st July 09, 04:54 AM
 McMurdo Yes indeed the fact that a... 21st July 09, 05:28 AM
 MacMillan of Rathdown What would the Victorians... 21st July 09, 11:25 AM
 thescot i think Jock's outfit is... 21st July 09, 11:29 AM
 MacMillan of Rathdown Dare one even think it? ... 21st July 09, 01:49 PM
 dfmacliam Dare I say, not one is... 21st July 09, 03:15 PM
 Bugbear Yes, I have noticed that... 22nd July 09, 12:58 AM
 DWFII Looks to me like there's a... 18th August 09, 04:42 PM
 Cavebear58 12345 18th August 09, 06:33 PM
 Kiltman Yes, a deerstalker would be... 18th August 09, 09:44 PM
 Welsh Buggy ROFL...Loved those comercials! 21st August 09, 07:42 PM
 Jock Scot Oh no! the trans-Atlantic... 23rd August 09, 02:28 AM
 MacMillan of Rathdown And the votes are pouring in... 24th August 09, 01:26 PM
 Kilted Rogue I have been looking at all... 22nd October 09, 05:21 PM
-
22nd July 09, 12:28 PM
#11
 Originally Posted by Phil
What is interesting from the pictures posted, however, is the sheer variety of the Victorians' dress which indicates that there was actually a great deal less conformity then than there is now.
One thing I like about photographic documentation versus painted portraiture when establishing "how it was done" is that with portraiture there is always a degree of uncertainty about how the artist translated what they were seeing into the picture.
Most of us can spot the differences between knife pleats, box pleats and Reverse Kingussie (for instance), but a portrait painter may or may not have portrayed it accurately.
More specifically to Phil's comment, that's very insightful! The farther we are -- geographically, in time, or culturally -- from "how it was done," the fewer examples we have to draw upon to determine what's "right." Seeing these old photographs (and the coloured cuts that were done by one familiar with the topic) definitely opens up a lot of interesting discussions about how it's done now.
:ootd:
Dr. Charles A. Hays
The Kilted Perfesser
Laird in Residence, Blathering-at-the-Lectern
-
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
|
|