Well.... I've rethought this. I agree that it looks better, but after I posted the pictures, I started comparing it again to the "display" model on the scotweb site, and I'm convinced the sides should hang more parallel to each other. It just looks too wide at the bottom.

So, I'm sending them both back. Sigh. Someday I'll run across someone making that style where I can try it on first-hand.

But thanks for the opinions!

On the upside, I decided to order an argyle jacket and vest combo from USA Kilts. They have an option for "long" as well, so I'll keep my fingers crossed!