So what is the rabbles opinion of this subject?
How would you approach it? Have I done the right thing?
Or am I making too much of it?

I feel I'm correct in asking for documentation of the Clanranald connection, and in asking that the info not be amended without proper documentation (I've mentioned that a note could be added that research is on-going & changes will be made if warranted).
Another question to ponder:

if a change is made listing my McReynolds/MacRanalds as septs of Clanranald without documentation, should I continue as my cousin above convinced that they are of Keppoch until documentation states otherwise?

(I already know the answer, I'm just curious what the rabble thinks )