Quote Originally Posted by Alan H View Post
Incredibly, I also agree with MoR on this one, at least partially. The Caddiemaster has rules, he has to do his best to interpret them, and he did so. That's his job. I would not come down too terribly hard on the Caddiemaster on this one, though it might have been wise to at least SEE Jeff before pronouncing judgement.

Now, the notion of not being able to play golf at a course in Scotland while wearing a kilt, that's really a different issue from what the Caddiemaster did. The Club Rules say what they say.......

and IMHO the Club Rules are on the far side of totally stupid. It's GOLF in SCOTLAND, for heavens sake. The idea of saying that you're not allowed to play golf in a kilt on a course in Scotland is so stupid that it leaves me without words. The Club should change its rules.

...but the Caddiemaster just did his job. He's not responsible for making the rules, he's responsible for enforcing them to the best of his ability.
OK clearly I have missed something here, but where in the rules as quoted does it say that kilts cannot be worn?