I do okay with a very simple pair of oxfords. They have versatility and range. I don't think they look out of place, even among ghille brogues. They are so understated that nobody ever notices them in a good or bad way, and they work with a suit for those rare times I decide to not go kilted. I like not needing another pair of shoes just because I put on p@nt$.

I bought a pair of Ghillators from Sport Kilt(by accident I swear...I was in a hurry to get to work and clicked the wrong pic and didn't catch it until they showed up on my doorstep). All I can say is if you like like Crocs...you'll still hate the stupid things! The only good thing is that they are dishwasher safe, but I won't wear them so they never get dirty. I only still have them because I kept forgetting to send them back until it was too late.