As my Granny MacLeod used to say- you can't put a German collar on a poodle and call it a shepherd. A kilt is a kilt is a kilt, no matter where it's made or the accent of the person making it. How is a USA Kilts Premiere not a kilt just because Rocky is not Scottish? Or a Tewksbury- is that not a kilt simply because it's made in New Mexico?