Has anyone seen these Dirks in person? are they decent?

[Hipbilly]

I was poking around the internet for a "regimental" dirk (the sort with chow tools included), and found THIS on eBay. After a quick google, i also found they offer one like THIS, but it's not on eBay therefore not very easy for me to purchase... It seems to be a decent knife, being advertized as High Carbon Steel, but I cannot find ANYTHING on who makes it, rockwell hardness, fit & finish, etc etc etc... For $130, i wouldn't expect too much, but I'd hope it would be on par with the Windlass and Cold Steel dirks.
They carry some well respected products, but they also carry the costume grade ones seen here and there...
I'm probably going to take the plunge for education's sake, but I figured I'd ask ya'll first.

I like the blade shape and overall styling on the earlier model, but I like the vertical mounting of the knife and fork better.

Here's the eBay one:


Here's the other: