There seems to have been a little discussion in this thread at how useful this list might be. As I stated, each person can look at this list and use it how they want (or not use it at all!). Although there are many things that go into making a kilt, I think for most people PRICE is the best place to start (especially on the first few kilts) and then move on from there. It should not be the only thing to look at, but probably will be one of the first. From there the consumer can look at other things that are important to them: customer service, experience, training, materials, etc.

I am not sure if this is worthy of being a "sticky" thread, but I think it would be a good idea to have some place where people can comment on and rate different kilt makers. Although, that might be hard since advertising is paid for on here. Not sure if that would be considered advertising or not.