I have a solid black sk and a swk blackwatch thrifty. I am growing to appreciate my thrifty but I love my SK. It is extremely comfortable, will fit perfectly if I gain or drop 50 pounds, and is just damn pretty (sewn down pleats are a must). I have heard complaints about sport kilt's tartans looking cheap, but I must say I think my solid black can be the dressiest thing I own. I highly recommend it.

Then again I've never tried any of the others and my tastes are hardly traditional or typical in any way, so what do I know?