I have both
Isle of Skye 16oz 8 yard Locharron Wool by the Scottish Company

Maple Leaf 13oz 5 yard Marton Mills PV by Canadian Casual Kilts

I love my country I really do, however I prefer the Isle of Skye it may be because mine is wool while my Maple Leaf is PV but the colours are just so subtle, the kilt really feels good you know you are wearing something special when you are in the Isle of Skye.