I can't help out with your question mainly because I have a few myself about these?

1. Are these type of kilts pretty popular? I'm curious as to how many of the rabble on here with traditional kilts actually have one of these and use them?

2. For those who do have one, do you tend to wear them more frequently than a normal kilt?

3. Does anyone ever get any sort of criticism from wearing one of these?

I'm starting to warm up to the idea of getting one, but I'd appreciate some input from the rabble to help me in shaping my opinions...