Hi Jock, you're correct to a point....proximity to the kilt maker, for a good fitting, is most desirable. The thread does NOT show one of an improper fit, it shows one of an improper build/construction.

Many Xmembers have had kilts made without a fitting, but still receive a quality product. I have two wonderfully made kilts, one from a well known US kilt maker, and I never had a fitting, but still ended up with a wonderful product.

Just my .02 cents.