2nd kilt advice

[MinusHD]

It's happened sooner than I expected... After a few successful outings in an Original Sport Kilt (which is a wee bit too short) I'm officially in the market for my 2nd kilt. I've decided on a tartan, I'm pretty sure I've selected my kilt maker/vendor. I'm still deciding between 5 yard wool vs. 8 yard wool, and still debating 2 vs. 3 straps.

The advice I need concerns kilt length. Heck, I already got one that's too short, right? I don't want to do that again. I've looked at many "how to measure" instructions, including those of the vendor of choice, so I can get a proper measurement and double/triple check it. What I can't get is a feel for how a traditional kilt will feel once I'm wearing it. I have read many posts on true waist, rise, straps, mid-knee, etc. Perhaps I simply missed it. Have any of you ever had an issue where the fit of a kilt on your body made you wish it had been ordered either longer or shorter... even when you were certain the measurements were absolutely correct?

Also, how much "tolerance" can one expect with the height at which a kilt is worn at, or near, the true waist (therefore allowing some adjustment in length)?

I really appreciate any input before I invest hundreds of dollars on a fancy garment.

Thanks you!

[Mikilt]

Talk with your kiltmaker. Not all kiltmakers use the same measurements. Use your kiltmaker's measuring instructions.

Edited: Sorry, I didn't read your post carefully enough. You already have talked with your kiltmaker.

[Kilted cabin boy]

In my case, I have two kilts.One semi-traditional and one 5 yard both made by Rocky at USA kilts. I measured by his instructions and decided the length should be 25 -
25 1/2. I decided on 25, but my second kilt I went to 25 1/2 for the length . Better to be a little to long, than too short.Use a large beach towel and fold it the different lengths to see what it might feel and look like. I will have any future kilts made to the same measurements so hopefully I will stay at the same weight. I don't know what vendor you have picked but Rocky's customer service is second to none. Good luck.

[TheOfficialBren]

I'd buy one of Rocky's 5-yard kilts and be done with it they fit GREAT, look FANTASTIC, and are easy on the pocket book.

I recommend 5 yards over 8-yards because you are in North Texas. I am in Bakersfield, California. Our climates are similar. I wouldn't wear a tank (8-yards) out here except on the coolest of days. 5 yards is just right.

As for the feel, it's heaven, mate. I never wear my P/V kilt at all these days. 16-ounce wool will spoil you.

[MinusHD]

As for the feel, it's heaven, mate. I never wear my P/V kilt at all these days. 16-ounce wool will spoil you.

Would dropping to a 13-ounce wool tartan ever make you consider an 8 yard kilt? I may only have the option of 13-ounce.

[Godot]

I only have really worn the lighter PV kilts, and have just received a new 18oz 5yd, but I know many kilted gentleman have expressed that they like the 13oz for the more manageable weight. If it's your only choice then that would help narrow things down just a bit.

[Richrail]

I have 3 of Rockys casual kilts and one Semi-Traditional and a 5 Yard wool 16oz. I love the wool for dressing nice or just getting out and about town. But the PV's are really great for hiking in the desert in the summer heat and working in the yard, and I love that they are machine washable.

[Norbo]

what ever you go for id go for the 3 straps over 2 they just look better

[BCAC]

In my case, I have two kilts.One semi-traditional and one 5 yard both made by Rocky at USA kilts. I measured by his instructions and decided the length should be 25 -
25 1/2. I decided on 25, but my second kilt I went to 25 1/2 for the length . Better to be a little to long, than too short.Use a large beach towel and fold it the different lengths to see what it might feel and look like. I will have any future kilts made to the same measurements so hopefully I will stay at the same weight. I don't know what vendor you have picked but Rocky's customer service is second to none. Good luck.

In my not so humble opinion, nobody is ever that close. Half an inch difference is unnoticeable. Most kilts, even if made to measure or bespoke, will drop half in inch in the course of a day.

[BCAC]

what ever you go for id go for the 3 straps over 2 they just look better

Your opinion. Not gospel. I prefer 2. My opinion is that they look better and perform better. The third strap has no use.